注册 登录  
 加关注
3news .newscnt li tmpl_
spanghome" t .newfindf"> follter-ow"}.m--y3 .uegInitialter-ow"}.m- ter-ow"}.m--y3 .udshow" har"/
ter.com/er-ow"}.m-dshow" r_tm .catussCtu"yft:10px;dth:atussCtu fg);-we><= =
=
= =y:noft:10pxspanx3777=y:noft:10pxmatusss="fl tatu">如果您是法官sspan> bgc0 scn7 fw0 ssg.1sspan> pspanx3 ter-ow""> .p9-10-15 19:17:51sspan> ber-ow"">|s="nbws="nbw分类:sspan><92094vege/4ve4veW0950950850870890/m/85094veW074092_20log.16默认分类">默认分类spx">& ff77777777=span> ber-ow"dshow" pfoll$|s="nbws="nbw标签:sspan><=span> scn3sshow" pfoll$<< pne;}. scn7ass="fl"span> ber-ow"">|sspan>foll$_spanReporu"yft:10px;cnt m2a">举报sspan>< pne;}. scn7ass="fl"span> ber-ow"">|sspan>ft:10pxzihao scn3xpfoll$_f> zihaoend- dshow" pfoll$ zihaoc?frcgss=span> me g">sspan> scn4im1 g">大sspan>yft:10pxscn4im1 g" >中sspan>yft:10pxscn4im1 g">小sspan>sspan> span>sspan> pne;}. ptu fcnt"pfoll$ iv id="ox-shadow 919 spyft:10pxm2ass订阅spx"foll$_shx gBtn_a> 2_20log.16分享到 "yft:10pxow2dim/rea> fgbkan>foll$_shx gBtn_ .qqweibo2_20log.16分享到新浪微博"yft:10pxow2dim/re .qqwb fgbkan>foll$_shx gBtn_qq2_20log.16分享到QQ空间"yft:10pxow2dim/reqqz fgbkan>foll$_shx gBtn_qqweibo2_20log.16分享到腾讯微博"yft:10pxow2dim/reqqweibo fgbkan> 2dim6062; scn6 3 11851849eW00991 h=;> fxtjss="ib42e" 5 用微信s="nbws="nbw“扫一扫”将文章分享到 圈。&n= 777777777777=y:nofoll$_shx gBtn_yixin2_20log.16分享到易信"yft:10pxow2dim/reyixin fgbkan> 2dim6062; scn6 3 11851849eW00991 h=;> fxtjss="ib42e" 6">用易信s="nbws="nbw“扫一扫”将文章分享到 圈。&n= 7777777777= " rel>围观最萌宠物a ? &77777777777777=pyft:10pxpne;}. scnt dire_20150513_03')"> " rel> 业恼掌閟="nbws="nbw|ss"> = 7777=y:noft:10pxb scn5 sc11siew-spogass="fl"Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em ss="nbw

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s这案子特小特简单。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s案情是这样的:ssP>&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s某学校在1986年开办一个校办工厂,该校办工厂经工商局a zt,具有独立法人资格。工厂租赁学校的房屋,从事印刷业务。某甲是该校办工厂的职工。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s1996年该校办工厂停产,工厂财产变卖一空,房屋退租,某甲和工友均放假回家。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s1997年,该校办工厂被工商局吊销营业执照,工厂名实双亡。学校没有对工厂进行清算,也没有给某甲及其他职工发过生活费。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s某甲自己为自己缴纳养老保险费。至W008年,某甲退休,共计缴纳养老保险金5.8&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s退休后,某甲向仲裁委员会提起仲裁,要求学校报销自己缴纳的养老保险金5.8&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s仲裁委员会裁定不予受理。某甲遂向法院提起诉讼。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s如果您是法官,您认为学校应不应该给某甲报销这5.8&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s这案子已经经过了劳动仲裁s="nbw、一审和二审,劳动仲裁是以超过时效不予受理,一审法院是以主体不适格驳回起诉,二审法院判决某甲胜诉。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em s我是一个律师,自始至终参与了该案的审理,我奇怪的是,同是审判,为什么观点这么不同。所以写此博文求教于方家。

&n=Pim1 im rTEXT-INDENT: 2em ss="nbwssP>= "<= &n "/
&n "/
&n v>v
spanghome" t .neofollwumiiRelmmedI sss=spv > ptc""> iv id="bcm?fr ss="nbw"/span> nbc-0siec-0-40 ptcmt ptcmt- 评论这张sspan><<"yft:10pxptc show"sss="fl ptc""> nbc-0siec-0-40 ptcmi"> "yft:10pxtoL> _20log.16发布到 "y} "yft:10pxptc show"sss="fl ptc""> nbc-0siec-0-40 ptcmi">< fcn7">targ(rspan>foll$_spaniReadCoutu">118sspan><)sspan> ow" fcn7">|sspan>< fcn7">评论(rspan>foll$_spaniCwwmentCoutu">2sspan><)sspan><<< fr imacn1 icn1-4">"yft:10pxpspanlblplblp-ne;u fcn7">|sspan><foll$_shx gBtn_a> _20log.16分享到 "yft:10pxow2dim/rea> fgbkan>foll$_shx gBtn_ .qqweibo_20log.16分享到新浪微博"yft:10pxow2dim/re .qqwb fgbkan>foll$_shx gBtn_qq_20log.16分享到QQ空间"yft:10pxow2dim/reqqz fgbkan>foll$_shx gBtn_qqweibo_20log.16分享到腾讯微博"yft:10pxow2dim/reqqweibo fgbkan> 2dim6062; scn6 3 11851849eW00991 h=;> fxtjss="ib42e"1a s用微信s="nbws="nbw“扫一扫”将文章分享到 圈。&n= 777777777777=y:nofoll$_shx gBtn_yixin_20log.16分享到易信"yft:10pxow2dim/reyixin fgbkan> 2dim6062; scn6 3 11851849eW00991 h=;> fxtjss="ib42e"1 用易信s="nbws="nbw“扫一扫”将文章分享到 圈。&n= 7777777777= "pfollow2diToL> Fir"ce"ethooll穙st_20围观最萌宠物ow2dif="/? smlden" namloadhirdIdxporauloafks_08306708508ive7068ve4ve50820950850870890/m/85094veW074092_2163-co77777777777777rinpu
smlden" namloaget=xporauloaa> POST 163-co77777777777777rinpu
smlden" namloa0log.xporauloa如果您是法官 163-co77777777777777rinpu
smlden" namloan> smlden" namloasourcexporauloa和风 163-co77777777777777rinpu
smlden" namloasource xporauloa> 11851849eW00991 smlden" namloa1 g"porauloa 163-co777777777777 77777777=y:noft:10pxpne;}. ne;}.ot不秙span>< f-myLikeIn>"pfoll$_spaniv cRcowwmend oft:10pxpspanlrd dshow" har 777777777777rspan> pspan onafcnt"hrspan>foll$_spanReowwmendCoutu">0sspan><人sspan> pspan iv id="ox-shadow 722siew-tgl1sias-ox-slearss="nbw"/span>rspan> pspan iv id="ox-shadow 621siew-tgl0sias-ox-slearss="nbw"/span>rspan> fcn7">sspan><|s="nbw< 777777=
7777=
77=
77=y:noft:10pxsn"yft:10pxp ml?- wb?frs2?frcg?rd ntxpfoll$_y:nRcowwmendC>= &_zoom:17>= ;visibrlity:smlden;d7d7 :0; eyt .00;lofr.m-w:smlden;xpft:10pxt .nor><= ;visibrlity:smlden;d7d7 :0; eyt .00;lofr.m-w:smlden;xpfoll x gditm" rel= x gd t .norywrap 777777=h4pft:10px wb?frs2?frcg fcn7 ssg.1热度m" 4d<= mmldtl dxpb yle icn1 icn1-4">>< ml?frompersonal"jximg fr imalay:block;poxpfollspanmmldtl d?fr i_blank"> 77777777=y:nofollfne;ha wr pft:10pxfne;ha wr >= mml_color: im1 im randtag phide"> d7d7 ="59-ce eyt .=";> ceunt .lay:bl="0" pv磖e謘ngg.16" oz-ow);-wepx ghcyck icn0>= color:<<在 的v cl文章m" 4d %;lofr.m-w:smlden;x< vtxt&ewn>wmend=pog? =kfwsm19p:@ "<= color:<> f="/on:c dxpb yle icn1 icn1-4">ver-style0 6px:t:5hov><<<关闭spspan>ammron:-4">&_2s" rel>围观最萌宠蝊20= wmenu">&n 777777=y:noft:10pxss="fl" <= = Perm="_nk:'',\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<这案子特小特简单。ssP\>\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<案情是这样的:ssP\>\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<某学校在1986年开办一个校办工厂,该校办工厂经工商局a zt,具有独立法人资格。工厂租赁学校的房屋,从事印刷业务。某甲是该校办工厂的职工。ssP\>\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<1996年该校办工厂停产,工厂财产变卖一空,房屋退租,某甲和工友均放假回家。ssP\>\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<1997年,该校办工厂被工商局吊销营业执照,工厂名实双亡。学校没有对工厂进行清算,也没有给某甲及其他职工发过生活费。ssP\>\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<某甲自己为自己缴纳养老保险费。至W008年,某甲退休,共计缴纳养老保险金5.8\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<退休后,某甲向仲裁委员会提起仲裁,要求学校报销自己缴纳的养老保险金5.8\r\n=Pim1 im \"TEXT-INDENT: 2em\"\<仲裁委员会裁定不予受理。某甲遂向法院提起诉讼。ssP\>\r\n=P\<= P\>', 11851849eW00991',<:'',<:'1',wBpogCoutu:'0', _ .qgle:'=pysml?frompersonale0 26rue4e4eus="6us=12520219/">r?frionl ad="imgwn?frip: Ig&gr(iown?fr.mg'=\'> _ .qgle&t=\'+ Dmme().spaTime(ef=lay:bl="0" mg')">rroroadhis.mg'=erctaron.f -cpft:10pxcwds wa?frcgsimg')"${fn1(x.visi莖rNaml)}&r=${visi莖r.og&grUpdmmeTime}"_brroroadhis.mg'=erctaron.f -cpft:10pxcwds wa?frcgsimg')"${fn1(x.visi莖rNaml)}"_b  hrspan>0log.16来自/spa手机nk" cpft:10pxiv id="wapIn><>rs"> '}0log.16来自iPh4">" Ф薱pft:10pxiv id="iph4">In><>rs"> 0log.16来自argroid" Ф薱pft:10pxiv id="te/roidIn><>rs"> '} hrspan>0log.16来自/spa短信写博"yft:10pxiv id="wapIn><>rs">   { co}r?frift:10px wa?frcg ptu" 4">rroroadhis.mg'=erctaron.f6-cpmg')"${fn1(a.uyleNaml)}"_b=s"> =py0${fn(a.esc{naml,8)|escape}=s"> =y:noft:10pxihtro scn5 ${a.限謋Intro|escape}{if g gdt260}${supspment}{ co}= s="nbwssy:nd譩=s"> 77=sy:nb=py0${fn(x.0log.,26)|escape}=s"><萍龉馄罩镜娜耍簊sp<wmendleNaml}/">wmendleNollnaml|escape}" 4">rroroadhis.mg'=erctaron.f -cpft:10pxcwds wa?frcgsimg')"${fn1(x.ewn>wmendleNaml)}"_b wmendleNaml}/">wmendleNsc{naml,6)|escape} 0}他们还<萍隽耍簊sp<rspanlft:10pxiv id=">s#183;sspan>wmendBpogPerm="_nk}/?get=ter('> 11851849eW00991${y.ewn>wmendBpogTlog.|escape}=s">转载-4 :sspan><s#183;sspan><rspan<=a }${x.ewferBpogTlog.|escape}=s">rsy:nbrspan<=a }${x.ewfertyleNaml|escape}=s">rsy:nb=py0${x.0log.|defa客 :""|escape}=s">=py0${x.0log.|defa客 :""|escape}=s">=py0wmendReader_20log.16${x.bpogTrl>|defa客 :""|escape}">${x.bpogTrl>|defa客 :""|escape}=s">4}{b gdk}{ co}${fn1(x.0log.,60)|escape}=s">${fn2(x.发现 shTime,'yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss')}sspan><=py0${fn(x.0log.,26)|escape}=s">s="nbwssspan>=pyft:10pxm2as s" rel>${bpogDetl.=""BpogTlog.|escape}=s"> irgnliv id="ox-shadow 619 =pyft:10pxm2as s" rel>${bpogDetl.n="/BpogTlog.|escape}=s">rroroadhis.mg'=erctaron.f -cpft:10pxcwds wa?frcgsimg')"${fn1(x.发现 shertylenaml)}&r=${visi莖r.og&grUpdmmeTime}"_brroroadhis.mg'=erctaron.f -cpft:10pxcwds wa?frcgsimg')"${fn1(x.发现 shertylenaml)}"_b  s="nbwss"> =sy:nb/spa新闻=sy:nbr/"/a><${headon:rs.0log.|escape}sspan><0}7}{b gdk}{ co}rpysml?frompersonale0·sspan><${x.0log.|escape}=s"> / sa /">下载/spa新闻" Ф "part4">r/onbr/onbr/onbr/onbr/onbr/onbrpy0v cl"par par=s">&_zoom:17><= _ .qglex>r/y:nbr/y:nb<= r/y:nbs="nbwssspan>r/y:nbs="nbws="nbw投票给s="nbws="nbws="nbws="nbw${fn1(x.v<v
spanghome" t .ne 11851849eW00991v v
spanghome" t .neimg')">r/>v v
spanghome" t .neimg')"> 3rd/js/0.1.0/ts_ad.jsssr/>v v
spanghome" t .ne v c>s="nbwssy:nb c>s="nbwssy:nb c>s="nbwssy:nbs="nbwr/y:nb c>s="nbwssy:nbs="nbwr/y:nbry:noft:10pxwkg h spaccx>ry:noft:10pxt h">s="nbwr/y:nbry:noft:10pxr h">s="nbwr/y:nbry:noft:10pxc h">s="nbwr/y:nbr/y:nb=/y:nb页脚ssh2> 7777ry:noft:10pxk">777777rpy"ht="noan> 业恼掌=s">pan> 777777rpy"ht="noan>nk" 风格=s">pan> 777777rpy"ht="noan>手机nk" =s">pan> 777777rpy"ht="noan>围观最萌宠/a ? pan>rspanlft:10pxfcn8 ifoll$_f>ot_subpv b" hrspan> iv id="m2aaox-shadow 919 spyft:10pxm2aafcn8 >订阅此博客=s">r/>pan> 7777=/y:nb/spa公司版权所有s="nbw©1997-us=7ssp<r/y:nbr/y:nbwilayer_>r/y:nb 77ry:noft:10px" itpl-ie-irgeashow" 2follbpog- -n>wi ptmme_2b yle icn1 icn1-4">&">77=f="/x gd rows="a .res="a naml="jat ifollie-jat-aa s77=py"ht="noan> pecial/007525FT/bpog.html b13azea s帮助=s">s="nbwr/>pan> 77=pyft:10pxpr_20${u}ss">${x.g}ssy:nb${y.n}ss">${x.n}ss">{/list}v
spanghome" t .ne wmon/facc602png'r 77erctaron.f140p:'>wmon/facc1402png'r 77erctaron.f40 =ea>cmmron.f140r 77erctaron.adf140p:'>wmon/admi" racc1402png'r 77erctaron.eptip:'>wmon/ pty2png'r 77erctaron.guml?_profrl>_addp:'>wmon/guml?_profrl>_add.gif'r 77erctaron.phtoto_d gdm-p:'>bpog/wr BpogCoz-b 'r 77wghdow.CF-p:{ 7777ca:false 777,mml:-3 777,cb:'' 777,cc:false 777,cd:false 777,ce:'-3' 777,ck:0 777,ci:['api/ter-qbbkdbmc'/",lpprtek/",l",la> archive/"] 777,cf:0 777,co:{pv:false 7777777,ti: .2358533 7777777,t<:'' 7777777,tc:0 7777777,tl:3 7777777,ut:0 7777777,u<:'' 7777777,um:'' 7777777,ui:0 7777777,ud:trul} 777,cp:{nr:1 7777777,cr:1 7777777,vr:-100 7777777,fr:0}v v
spanghome" t .neimg')">r/>v v
spanghome" t .neimg')">r/>v v htes.jssi0onl="f="//java>v ">r/>v v <0onl="f="//java>v "> 7777_htes_nacc='ter-';:#teascT ker()r 7777 7777 Im&gr().mg'-p:'> yleshog&grs/analyse2png?s=p&t='+ Dmme().spaTime(er 77r/>v v >v ','//3">蝕oogle-analytics蝞>w/analytics蝚s','ga')r 77ga('c gdte', 'UA-692049 -1', 't .o')r 77ga('send', 'ylesview')r },30.)r ="no r/>v 7v i0onl="f="//java>v "> 7777wghdow.setTimeout(fun ron(){adSv ('>cmmron. wr,'MusicBeanNew','>etCopyne;}.MusicSessronToken',false)r },=0e.)r r/>v v >v ip:document.c gdteEspment('>v ')r 7777>v .async-p:1r 77 pv磇pt.mg'-p:'>r/>v </